Organised Violence and Torture
in Zimbabwe

IRCT
Harare and Copenhagen - June 06, 2000


Contents   «   »

5. Findings

Prev case  Next case
5.1 Cases seen (Cont'd)
5.1.5 Case E:

History
Mr M.S an MDC supporter and brother of an MDC Coordinator was abducted in the 13th May at 8 p.m. by 5 people, some of whom wore ZANU PF T shirts and taken to Budiriro 4. He was singled out in his opinion because his brother is a well-known MDC Coordinator. On the way to the surgery he suffered beating to his genitals. At the Clinic he suffered 4 days of beating and ill treatment. He was kept in a toilet during daytime and in a Landrover outside the clinic at night. He was kicked and beaten with a broomstick in his back, buttocks, feet and hands in a room with 16 people by someone referred to as the "Quartermaster" until he feigned lack of consciousness and was taken to a medical room. He suffered bleeding through the nose and mouth. His third day of torture was described as the worst. He was told to confess to being an MDC Supporter by 2 officers and a Commander known as Mataga. He was told to write a letter to his brother asking for his release. He was eventually released upon confession and went to the house of a friend. 2 war veterans have been arrested in connection with this incident

Previous medical history:
In good health prior to torture and never hospitalised.

Alleged Torture Methods

  • Psychological torture:
    Threats including death threats
    Threats to give up his political beliefs
    Sexual torture

  • Physical torture:
    Unsystematic beatings all over body until unconscious.
    Falanga.

Subjective Complaints
Headache, dizziness, back pain, pain while walking

Objective Physical Findings

  • Regio facialis: echymosis around the right eye and right part of the regio frontalis, 8 - 5 cm

  • Regio dorsalis, mamis sin: linear scar, 6 cm; three irregular scars without clear demarcation, 4 cm, 3 cm, 1-2 cm.

  • Regio dorsalis, regio limbalis dxt: excoriation, 10 - 5 cm;

  • Regio plantae pedis sin: 2 round scars, ½ cm diameter with oedema

  • Regio plantae pedis dex: 3 round scars, ½ cm diameter with oedema

Objective Psychological Findings
Nil

Conclusions
The objective findings correspond to alleged beating with fists in the face, alleged beating with a thin iron stick on the left hand, alleged beating with a brick on the left hand, and alleged falanga of both feet. The subjective complaints are consistent with the after-effects of psychological torture.  TOP