Who is responsible?
A preliminary analysis of pre-election violence
in Zimbabwe
June 20, 2000


Contents
   «    »

Militia Groups
At their core, the Zanu (PF) militias consist of individuals with experience of organised violence, usually war veterans. The rank and file of the groups are composed largely of unemployed youths who are being paid for their support. Most people believe they are receiving cash on a daily basis, but it is certain that at a minimum they are being paid "in kind" - they are given food, drink and accommodation and goods looted from houses, businesses or farms.

For the most part, militias are armed with iron bars, sjamboks, axes, pangas, electric wires, bicycle chains. Some groups are in possession of one or more guns, but there are few instances of these being used in day-to-day operations. There are reports of hit-squads being formed for specific missions and these are generally armed.

The size of the militia groups varies, although between 20-30 is an average figure for the core element in each group. These are supplemented by others during missions and several hundreds of Zanu (PF) supporters may unite to sweep through rural areas and carry out beatings. They have established operational bases, usually in rural district council offices or buildings owned by Zanu (PF) members at growth points and also in some urban districts. Camps have been established on occupied farms. Sometimes these are little more than meeting points where local Zanu (PF) supporters congregate regularly. In the majority of cases, however, they have become informal barracks, where youths are trained and provided with food and drink and are even sleeping at night. There have been allegations that the youths are also being supplied with drugs. People from other areas have sometimes been brought to stay at the bases and carry out attacks. The extent of the use of outsiders may be a reflection of the inability of the team to drum up sufficient locals, but many witnesses believe it is part of a strategy designed to limit identification of the attackers.

Raiders are despatched from the bases into surrounding communities to hunt down opposition supporters who are either brought back to be tortured, assaulted or intimidated or are brutalised in their homes, together with their families. There are often hundreds of participants in these raids, but there are indications that some may have been coerced into taking part and are not fully committed to violence. Several victims noted that the attackers are very young, possibly even school-going age. The mass of the attackers are apparently being rounded up when needed by the militias to boost their impact, but the core members usually carry out the beatings and torture themselves.

The extent to which the day-to-day activities of the militias are under direct control of the Zanu (PF) leadership is not certain. Nevertheless, the relationship between Zanu (PF) officials (including candidates) and the militias is strong, suggesting that the groups are implementing a policy under close guidance from members of the party. Accounts of financial rewards being offered for carrying out acts of violence are a signal of state involvement and the day-to-day costs of feeding and housing the militia are allegedly being met by Zanu (PF) candidates and senior party officials.

Regular reports of Central Intelligence Organisation (CIO) agents taking a direct hand in the violence reinforce the perception that the campaign is being led by the highest authorities in government. CIO members have made themselves known to a number of victims and are accused of acts of torture, threats and participation in attacks upon MDC members. In one case investigated by the Forum there is strong evidence that CIO members tortured an MDC member. The victim can identify his attackers and as such is now extremely vulnerable. Other members of his family received threats after the incident. The Amani Trust, which has been assisting with medical costs for the victim, has since received reports of several visits by the CIO to the Harare Central Hospital which have put the victim in further fear of his life. He is severely traumatised and physically ill.

Several victims have reported to the Forum that they were visited by CIO agents while in hospital. In one case in Bindura hospital the victim had to be transferred. A youth who was tortured by the militia in Mberengwa was forced to flee the hospital after a sympathetic doctor recognised that a CIO agent had been smuggled into a neighbouring bed in a wheelchair. Members of the CIO have also been observed organising the militias and transporting them from one place to another. There are also reports of Police Internal Security and Intelligence (PISI) involvement.

There are indications that individuals from the Zimbabwe National Army (ZNA) whose loyalty to the party is solid have been selected and deployed as commanders of the militia, but there is no firm proof of this at present. There are allegations that members of the army have been sighted at least one militia base - although in plain clothes they were recognised by locals who were themselves former soldiers. On the other hand, there are consistent accounts that the army took a firm hand to quell the violence in the Mount Darwin region in mid-April.

Allegations that the army are giving rudimentary two-day training sessions to the militia are not proven, but there is reason to believe that the perpetrators of violence have been given some basic education in torture techniques. Militia in different parts of the country are carrying out beatings in a consistent style, with victims being ordered to lie face down and then being beaten on the backs. Electric wires are frequently used for beatings as are sjamboks and knobkerries. Another common torture is falanga [beating under the soles of the feet] and the use of electric shocks and cigarette burns. On several occasions victims have been doused in petrol to burn them. Properties have also been frequently petrol bombed. There is also a consistency to the methods of psychological torture with victims being issued with similar threats to "cut off your head" and forced to go through similar rituals of humiliation. Forced attendance at the "pungwes" and political rallies inspires mass psychological terror which, in many people’s minds, is reminiscent of the terror inspired during the Gukurahundi campaign in the 1980s.   TOP